Is your organisation suffering from a conspiracy of stupidity?

Four warning signs — and what to do about them

Over the years, I've see a phenomenon I call a conspiracy of stupidity.

It's what happens when good people collectively keep their organisation in the dark about the very things it needs to know about to change for the better.

Sir Geoff Mulgan, Professor of Collective Intelligence at UCL, has a spicy take on why that happens: collective stupidity is worsened by two very human desires — we want to be lazy, and we want to be liked. "It's too much work to speak up. Why should I be the bad guy?"

Collective intelligence is hard to build. Ideally, decision-makers create psychologically safe conditions that help people be frank. Realistically, you don't always get that. So you also need people on the ground with the courage to share hard facts and sharp opinions — even at the risk of being disliked. That's more than most of us are prepared to offer.

I started thinking about this during my brief time as a Nominated Member of Parliament. There were just 9 of us citizens appointed to represent non-partisan interests. In that room, I felt how many issues went unseen and unheard simply because the people who cared most were not there to speak. I felt limited in my capacity to speak on every issue, and hesitant to share controversial views.

But staying silent out of convenience felt disrespectful — the whole point of big meetings (be it in Parliament or our organisations) is to make us all collectively wiser about what must be considered. Otherwise the meeting might as well be an email.

Choosing to speak takes far more prep work than we think. I put in weeks of prep for those speeches in Parliamentary meetings and still not everyone liked what I had to say. I learned you have to be OK with that.

Parliament taught me: if you keep waiting only for ideal conditions to speak, you will lose your voice — and your organisation loses an opportunity to listen, grow and change.

In my client work since, I've noticed four warning signs that we are enabling a collective silence in our organisation that conspires to keep all of us collectively stupid:

First, we have too many meetings after the meetings — surfacing our candid views only in WhatsApp chats or corridor conversations, not the room itself.

Second, we act overly passive and agreeable — enabling our leaders’ belief that we have nothing to say and encouraging them to have little curiosity about what's actually underneath our quiet surface.

Third, we resign ourselves to doing busywork — mindless details, passing the buck, pushing blame, shifting goalposts. Tasks that we don’t totally believe in, that distract us from talking more honestly about how to tackle the tougher problems we are avoiding.

Fourth, there is a familiar costly, persistent problem we all know about — but choose to deal with using informal, personal work-arounds rather than tabling it formally as a serious, professional discussion.

If you see two or more of these traits, you likely have collective stupidity brewing.

It’s crucial to understand this: your organisation isn't short on intelligence or voice.

It's just gotten used to keeping intelligence off the table.

The good news: this is fixable.

But you can’t just tell people to "speak up." Or put up posters on psychological safety.

You cannot treat your people as if they're stupid. You have to actually be that safer leader who makes speaking up easier and less risky.

Ask them what stupid things they'd like the organisation to stop doing. Welcome and listen to their tough opinions. If you can do that sincerely and not react defensively, you can still turn the tide of stupidity.

You may feel inexperienced at helping your people share more openly with you what’s going on.

You may feel unsure if you can share with your own decision-makers your own honest hopes and concerns.

You may feel convicted you must learn how to help yourself and your teams have such conversations so that things can change in your organisation.

If that’s where you’re at, I want to help you to start to change your organisation - one strategic conversation at a time.

It’s what I built Facilitating Conversations for Change for — over four days, I help leaders and change practitioners get more skillful and practiced at holding real conversations that lead to real change into the organisations they care about.

You'll leave with concrete practices backed by solid theories that will help you secure yourself before a hard conversation and put your values, convictions and concerns on the table.

There’s a lot of wisdom waiting to be tapped in all the conversations that your people are keeping off the table.

Help them find their voice and put their unspoken hopes, concerns and sentiments on the table. That’s how you can start rebuilding your organisation’s collective intelligence again.

If you have questions before registering, drop us an email. My team makes sure I read every one.

— Shiao

Shiao-Yin Kuik

Executive Director of Common Ground specialising in culture change, leadership development, and social impact strategy for mission-driven organisations. Her work helps leaders bridge the gap between what they value and how they actually work.

Currently in Year 7 of a 9-year government-commissioned civic engagement project, her consulting draws on two decades building, closing, and rebuilding organisations with integrity.

Previous
Previous

Lead Your AI. Don't Let It Lead You.

Next
Next

Stop Using Personality Tests Like a Hammer